Players who played for the Browns and the Colts

45 players · NFL since 2013

45 players have played for both the Browns and the Colts in the NFL since 2013. 24 played for the Browns first and 21 for the Colts first. The longest-serving played 87 games across both; the top scorer got 13 touchdowns; 3 scored for both; the first move came in 2013, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 45?

0/450:00

  1.  Browns 28 · Colts 59
  2.  Browns 18 · Colts 60
  3.  Browns 29 · Colts 46
  4.  Browns 16 · Colts 47
  5.  Browns 16 · Colts 47
  6.  Browns 46 · Colts 16
  7.  Browns 32 · Colts 27
  8.  Browns 41 · Colts 17
  9.  Browns 3 · Colts 54
  10.  Browns 1 · Colts 56
  11.  Browns 19 · Colts 38
  12.  Browns 16 · Colts 34
  13.  Browns 42 · Colts 2
  14.  Browns 27 · Colts 16
  15.  Browns 36 · Colts 7
  16.  Browns 33 · Colts 8
  17.  Browns 30 · Colts 7
  18.  Browns 24 · Colts 12
  19.  Browns 16 · Colts 19
  20.  Browns 2 · Colts 32
  21.  Browns 6 · Colts 27
  22.  Browns 4 · Colts 25
  23.  Browns 16 · Colts 12
  24.  Browns 13 · Colts 15
  25.  Browns 1 · Colts 26
  26.  Browns 1 · Colts 26
  27.  Browns 3 · Colts 23
  28.  Browns 7 · Colts 17
  29.  Browns 22 · Colts 2
  30.  Browns 17 · Colts 4
  31.  Browns 9 · Colts 12
  32.  Browns 18 · Colts 1
  33.  Browns 6 · Colts 12
  34.  Browns 10 · Colts 8
  35.  Browns 1 · Colts 16
  36.  Browns 2 · Colts 12
  37.  Browns 8 · Colts 4
  38.  Browns 6 · Colts 5
  39.  Browns 7 · Colts 4
  40.  Browns 9 · Colts 1
  41.  Browns 3 · Colts 5
  42.  Browns 3 · Colts 4
  43.  Browns 5 · Colts 1
  44.  Browns 1 · Colts 4
  45.  Browns 1 · Colts 1

Who stands out

Spoilers

Anthony Walker has the most games for the two combined: 28 for the Browns and 59 for the Colts. Jacoby Brissett scored the most touchdowns across both (2 for the Browns, 11 for the Colts), and 3 players scored for both.

In our data, Trent Richardson was the first to have played for both (his first game for the Colts came in 2013). The most recent player to play for both is Pharaoh Brown, who first played for the Colts in 2026.

Show all 45 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the Browns and the Colts (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
PlayerBrownsColtsFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
Anthony Walker2802021–20235902017–2020Colts
Matthew Adams18020236002018–2021Colts
Jabaal Sheard2902013–20144602017–2019Browns
Jacoby Brissett162202247112017–2020Colts
D'Qwell Jackson16020134722014–2016Browns
Barkevious Mingo4602013–20151602017Browns
T.J. Carrie3202018–20192722020–2021Browns
Ronnie Harrison4112020–20221712023–2024Browns
Chester Rogers3020225452016–2019Colts
Joe Haeg1020225602016–2019Colts
Pierre Desir1902014–20153802017–2019Browns
Taven Bryan16020223402023–2024Browns
Briean Boddy-Calhoun4212016–2018202019Browns
Rodney McLeod Jr.2722023–20241612022Colts
Ibraheim Campbell3602015–2017702020–2021Browns
Cameron Mitchell3302023–2025802025Browns
Trevon Coley3002017–2018702019Browns
Billy Winn2402013–20141202015Browns
Chase McLaughlin16020211902019–2022Colts
Trent Richardson2020133272013–2014Browns
Tony Brown6020242702022–2023Colts
T.Y. McGill402017–20242502015–2016Colts
Andrew Sendejo16020201202021Browns
Cam Johnson1302015–20161502013–2014Colts
Deon Jackson1020232632021–2023Colts
Cameron McGrone1020252602022–2025Colts
Robert Turbin3020152392016–2018Browns
Mekhi Blackmon7020261702025Colts
Pharaoh Brown2202019–2022202026Browns
Brian Hoyer1702013–2014402019Browns
Ifeadi Odenigbo9020211202022Browns
Genard Avery1802018–2019102024Browns
Isaac Rochell6020221202021Colts
Joe Flacco1002023–2025802024Browns
Matt Haack1020231602022Colts
Chris Williams2020261202021–2022Colts
Deon King802017402016Colts
Anthony Fabiano602016–2020502017Browns
Sheldon Day702021402020Colts
Malik Jefferson902019102021Browns
Lavar Edwards302017502016Colts
Kyle Kalis302018402017Colts
Carl Davis502018102019Browns
Charlie Whitehurst102016402015Colts
Matt Lengel102017102019Browns

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the Browns and the Colts have met 4 times: the Browns won 2, the Colts 2.

  • Browns' biggest win: Browns 32-23 Colts (2020)
  • Colts' biggest win: Colts 31-28 Browns (2017)

More pairs

Browns also shares players with

Every Browns pair

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the Browns and the Colts?
45 in the NFL since 2013: Anthony Walker, Matthew Adams, Jabaal Sheard, Jacoby Brissett, D'Qwell Jackson, Barkevious Mingo and 39 more.
Has anyone scored for both the Browns and the Colts?
Yes, 3: Jacoby Brissett (2 and 11), Rodney McLeod Jr. (2 and 1) and Ronnie Harrison (1 and 1).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the Browns and the Colts?
Pharaoh Brown. He played for the Browns (2019–2022), then the Colts from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.