Players who played for the Colts and the Titans

41 players · NFL since 2013

41 players have played for both the Colts and the Titans in the NFL since 2013. 26 played for the Colts first and 15 for the Titans first. The longest-serving played 94 games across both; the top scorer got 19 touchdowns; 2 scored for both; the first move came in 2013, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 41?

0/410:00

  1.  Colts 15 · Titans 79
  2.  Colts 42 · Titans 47
  3.  Colts 3 · Titans 80
  4.  Colts 66 · Titans 17
  5.  Colts 69 · Titans 10
  6.  Colts 54 · Titans 17
  7.  Colts 29 · Titans 42
  8.  Colts 61 · Titans 2
  9.  Colts 47 · Titans 13
  10.  Colts 36 · Titans 20
  11.  Colts 54 · Titans 1
  12.  Colts 37 · Titans 18
  13.  Colts 17 · Titans 34
  14.  Colts 4 · Titans 45
  15.  Colts 43 · Titans 2
  16.  Colts 16 · Titans 18
  17.  Colts 33 · Titans 1
  18.  Colts 1 · Titans 31
  19.  Colts 24 · Titans 7
  20.  Colts 9 · Titans 17
  21.  Colts 17 · Titans 8
  22.  Colts 16 · Titans 8
  23.  Colts 17 · Titans 5
  24.  Colts 16 · Titans 5
  25.  Colts 15 · Titans 5
  26.  Colts 4 · Titans 16
  27.  Colts 19 · Titans 1
  28.  Colts 8 · Titans 11
  29.  Colts 3 · Titans 15
  30.  Colts 2 · Titans 14
  31.  Colts 5 · Titans 10
  32.  Colts 5 · Titans 7
  33.  Colts 9 · Titans 2
  34.  Colts 4 · Titans 7
  35.  Colts 7 · Titans 3
  36.  Colts 7 · Titans 1
  37.  Colts 3 · Titans 5
  38.  Colts 2 · Titans 5
  39.  Colts 4 · Titans 1
  40.  Colts 1 · Titans 4
  41.  Colts 2 · Titans 1

Who stands out

Spoilers

Dennis Kelly has the most games for the two combined: 15 for the Colts and 79 for the Titans. Nick Westbrook-Ikhine scored the most touchdowns across both (0 for the Colts, 19 for the Titans), and 2 players scored for both.

In our data, Corey Lynch was the first to have played for both (his first game for the Colts came in 2013). The most recent player to play for both is Atonio Mafi, who first played for the Titans in 2026.

Show all 41 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the Colts and the Titans (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
PlayerColtsTitansFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
Dennis Kelly15020227922016–2020Titans
Denico Autry4202018–20204702021–2023Colts
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine30202680192020–2024Titans
Erik Walden6602013–20161702017Colts
Matt Overton6902013–20161002020Colts
Chester Rogers5452016–20191712021Colts
Al Woods2902017–20184202014–2016Titans
Kylen Granson6112021–2024202026Colts
Le'Raven Clark4702016–20201302022Colts
Chris Milton3602016–20182002019–2020Colts
Jordan Wilkins5442018–2022102021Colts
Matthias Farley3702016–20181802021Colts
Darrell Baker Jr.1702022–20233402024–2025Colts
Arden Key4020264502023–2025Titans
Jaylon Jones4302023–2025202026Colts
Akeem Ayers16020161802013–2014Titans
Taylor Stallworth3302020–2021102023Colts
Jeremy McNichols1020183122020–2021Colts
Marcus Johnson2432018–2020702021Colts
Jihad Ward902018–20191702025Colts
Jacob Martin1702023802026Colts
Andre Johnson1642015822016Colts
Samuel Womack1702024502025Colts
Tarell Basham1602017–2018502022Colts
JoJo Domann1512022502023Colts
Jamon Meredith4020141602014–2015Colts
Mike Badgley1902021–2025102021Titans
Shaun Phillips8020141102014Titans
Sean Spence3020171502016Titans
Chase Coffman2020161412014–2015Titans
Joe Bachie5020251002025Colts
Lavar Edwards502016702013Titans
John Simon912017202021Colts
Charlie Whitehurst402015702014Titans
Corey Lynch702013302013Titans
Antwaun Woods702021102016Titans
Atonio Mafi302024502026Colts
Arlington Hambright202023502024Colts
D'Joun Smith402015102016Colts
Deiontrez Mount102016402015Titans
Ryan Allen202020102020Titans

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the Colts and the Titans have met 27 times: the Colts won 18, the Titans 9.

  • Colts' biggest win: Colts 38-10 Titans (2018)
  • Titans' biggest win: Colts 26-45 Titans (2020)

More pairs

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

Titans also shares players with

Every Titans pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the Colts and the Titans?
41 in the NFL since 2013: Dennis Kelly, Denico Autry, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine, Erik Walden, Matt Overton, Chester Rogers and 35 more.
Has anyone scored for both the Colts and the Titans?
Yes, 2: Chester Rogers (5 and 1) and Andre Johnson (4 and 2).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the Colts and the Titans?
Atonio Mafi. He played for the Colts (2024), then the Titans from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.