Players who played for the Colts and the New York Jets

31 players · NFL since 2013

31 players have played for both the Colts and the New York Jets in the NFL since 2013. 18 played for the Colts first and 13 for the New York Jets first. The longest-serving played 85 games across both; the top scorer got 21 touchdowns; 1 scored for both; the first move came in 2014, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 31?

0/310:00

  1.  Colts 45 · Jets 40
  2.  Colts 29 · Jets 45
  3.  Colts 37 · Jets 29
  4.  Colts 2 · Jets 64
  5.  Colts 10 · Jets 54
  6.  Colts 48 · Jets 15
  7.  Colts 16 · Jets 42
  8.  Colts 38 · Jets 9
  9.  Colts 28 · Jets 13
  10.  Colts 25 · Jets 12
  11.  Colts 29 · Jets 6
  12.  Colts 4 · Jets 31
  13.  Colts 30 · Jets 3
  14.  Colts 5 · Jets 23
  15.  Colts 14 · Jets 12
  16.  Colts 17 · Jets 8
  17.  Colts 1 · Jets 22
  18.  Colts 8 · Jets 15
  19.  Colts 19 · Jets 1
  20.  Colts 8 · Jets 11
  21.  Colts 17 · Jets 1
  22.  Colts 15 · Jets 1
  23.  Colts 9 · Jets 6
  24.  Colts 14 · Jets 1
  25.  Colts 2 · Jets 11
  26.  Colts 4 · Jets 7
  27.  Colts 7 · Jets 3
  28.  Colts 8 · Jets 1
  29.  Colts 7 · Jets 1
  30.  Colts 3 · Jets 5
  31.  Colts 7 · Jets 1

Who stands out

Spoilers

Jonotthan Harrison has the most games for the two combined: 45 for the Colts and 40 for the New York Jets. Frank Gore scored the most touchdowns across both (19 for the Colts, 2 for the New York Jets), and 1 player scored for both.

In our data, Josh Cribbs was the first to have played for both (his first game for the Colts came in 2014). The most recent player to play for both is Carl Lawson, who first played for the Colts in 2026.

Show all 31 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the Colts and the New York Jets (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
PlayerColtsJetsFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
Jonotthan Harrison4502014–20164002017–2019Colts
Henry Anderson2902015–20174502018–2020Colts
Matthias Farley3702016–20182902019–2020Colts
Micheal Clemons2020266402022–2025Jets
Sauce Gardner1002025–20265402022–2025Jets
Frank Gore48192015–20171522020Colts
Tarell Basham1602017–20184202018–2020Colts
Pierre Desir3802017–2019912020Colts
Nate Hairston2802017–20181302019–2020Colts
Adonai Mitchell2502024–20251232025–2026Colts
Al Woods2902017–2018602023Colts
Antonio Cromartie4020163102013–2015Jets
Quincy Wilson3002017–2019302020Colts
Arthur Maulet5020182312019–2020Colts
Jelani Woods14320221202025–2026Colts
Jacob Martin1702023802022Jets
Carl Lawson1020262202022–2023Jets
Josh Andrews802018–20191502020Colts
Chase McLaughlin1902019–2022102020Colts
Joe Flacco8020241102020–2022Jets
Samuel Womack1702024102025Colts
Dennis Kelly1502022102023Colts
Josh Cribbs902014602013Jets
Spencer Shrader1402024–2026102024Colts
Ronald Martin2020171102015–2016Jets
Anthony Johnson402017702016Jets
D.J. Montgomery712023302021Jets
Josh Thomas802015102014Jets
Ibraheim Campbell702020–2021102018Jets
J.J. Wilcox302018502018Jets
Ross Travis702017–2019102020Colts

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the Colts and the New York Jets have met 6 times: the Colts won 4, the New York Jets 2.

  • Colts' biggest win: Jets 10-41 Colts (2016)
  • New York Jets' biggest win: Colts 7-20 Jets (2015)

More pairs

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

New York Jets also shares players with

Every New York Jets pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the Colts and the New York Jets?
31 in the NFL since 2013: Jonotthan Harrison, Henry Anderson, Matthias Farley, Micheal Clemons, Sauce Gardner, Frank Gore and 25 more.
Has anyone scored for both the Colts and the New York Jets?
Yes, 1: Frank Gore (19 and 2).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the Colts and the New York Jets?
Carl Lawson. He played for the New York Jets (2022–2023), then the Colts from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.