Players who played for the 49ers and the Colts

29 players · NFL since 2013

29 players have played for both the 49ers and the Colts in the NFL since 2013. 14 played for the 49ers first and 15 for the Colts first. The longest-serving played 160 games across both; the top scorer got 34 touchdowns; 3 scored for both; the first move came in 2014, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 29?

0/290:00

  1.  49ers 65 · Colts 95
  2.  49ers 46 · Colts 70
  3.  49ers 92 · Colts 1
  4.  49ers 35 · Colts 48
  5.  49ers 38 · Colts 31
  6.  49ers 51 · Colts 15
  7.  49ers 39 · Colts 18
  8.  49ers 13 · Colts 41
  9.  49ers 2 · Colts 48
  10.  49ers 12 · Colts 36
  11.  49ers 15 · Colts 32
  12.  49ers 32 · Colts 12
  13.  49ers 3 · Colts 40
  14.  49ers 26 · Colts 17
  15.  49ers 10 · Colts 31
  16.  49ers 36 · Colts 4
  17.  49ers 15 · Colts 25
  18.  49ers 4 · Colts 36
  19.  49ers 2 · Colts 33
  20.  49ers 16 · Colts 12
  21.  49ers 22 · Colts 3
  22.  49ers 20 · Colts 4
  23.  49ers 8 · Colts 16
  24.  49ers 3 · Colts 19
  25.  49ers 7 · Colts 4
  26.  49ers 6 · Colts 4
  27.  49ers 5 · Colts 1
  28.  49ers 3 · Colts 1
  29.  49ers 1 · Colts 2

Who stands out

Spoilers

DeForest Buckner has the most games for the two combined: 65 for the 49ers and 95 for the Colts. Frank Gore scored the most touchdowns across both (15 for the 49ers, 19 for the Colts), and 3 players scored for both.

In our data, Antoine Bethea was the first to have played for both (his first game for the 49ers came in 2014). The most recent player to play for both is Arden Key, who first played for the Colts in 2026.

Show all 29 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the 49ers and the Colts (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
Player49ersColtsFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
DeForest Buckner6512016–20199512020–202649ers
George Odum4602022–20247002018–2025Colts
Kyle Nelson9202014–202010202149ers
Frank Gore35152013–201448192015–201749ers
Samson Ebukam3802021–20223102023–202549ers
Charvarius Ward5112022–20241502025–202649ers
Antoine Bethea3912014–20161802013Colts
Rock Ya-Sin13020244102019–2021Colts
Marlon Mack20202248232017–2021Colts
Hassan Ridgeway12020223602016–2018Colts
Matt Pryor15020233202021–2022Colts
Mike Person3202018–20191202017Colts
Kemoko Turay3020224002018–2021Colts
Samuel Womack2602022–2023170202449ers
Trey Sermon10120213122023–202449ers
Sheldon Day3602017–201940202049ers
T.Y. McGill1502022–20242502015–2016Colts
Zach Kerr4020213602014–2016Colts
Matt Gay2020253302023–2024Colts
Darryl Morris1602013120201649ers
Cassius Marsh2202017–201830202049ers
Arden Key200202140202649ers
Tavon Wilson8020211602020Colts
Chase McLaughlin3020191902019–202249ers
Khalid Kareem702026402022Colts
Brian Hoyer61201740201949ers
Jeremy McNichols502017–202310201849ers
Khalil Davis302024102021Colts
Briean Boddy-Calhoun102020202019Colts

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the 49ers and the Colts have met 4 times: the 49ers won 1, the Colts 3.

  • 49ers' biggest win: Colts 27-48 49ers (2025)
  • Colts' biggest win: 49ers 7-27 Colts (2013)

More pairs

49ers also shares players with

Every 49ers pair

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the 49ers and the Colts?
29 in the NFL since 2013: DeForest Buckner, George Odum, Kyle Nelson, Frank Gore, Samson Ebukam, Charvarius Ward and 23 more.
Has anyone scored for both the 49ers and the Colts?
Yes, 3: Frank Gore (15 and 19), Trey Sermon (1 and 2) and DeForest Buckner (1 and 1).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the 49ers and the Colts?
Arden Key. He played for the 49ers (2021), then the Colts from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.