Players who played for the Colts and the Steelers

25 players · NFL since 2013

25 players have played for both the Colts and the Steelers in the NFL since 2013. 15 played for the Colts first and 10 for the Steelers first. The longest-serving played 98 games across both; the top scorer got 26 touchdowns; 2 scored for both; the first move came in 2014, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 25?

0/250:00

  1.  Colts 95 · Steelers 3
  2.  Colts 17 · Steelers 79
  3.  Colts 8 · Steelers 68
  4.  Colts 1 · Steelers 69
  5.  Colts 56 · Steelers 13
  6.  Colts 2 · Steelers 61
  7.  Colts 56 · Steelers 5
  8.  Colts 28 · Steelers 24
  9.  Colts 5 · Steelers 43
  10.  Colts 29 · Steelers 16
  11.  Colts 3 · Steelers 39
  12.  Colts 5 · Steelers 34
  13.  Colts 31 · Steelers 4
  14.  Colts 18 · Steelers 17
  15.  Colts 30 · Steelers 1
  16.  Colts 14 · Steelers 16
  17.  Colts 16 · Steelers 13
  18.  Colts 10 · Steelers 13
  19.  Colts 16 · Steelers 2
  20.  Colts 12 · Steelers 4
  21.  Colts 7 · Steelers 8
  22.  Colts 3 · Steelers 12
  23.  Colts 9 · Steelers 1
  24.  Colts 3 · Steelers 2
  25.  Colts 1 · Steelers 1

Who stands out

Spoilers

Michael Pittman has the most games for the two combined: 95 for the Colts and 3 for the Steelers. Eric Ebron scored the most touchdowns across both (18 for the Colts, 8 for the Steelers), and 2 players scored for both.

In our data, Darrius Heyward-Bey was the first to have played for both (his first game for the Steelers came in 2014). The most recent player to play for both is Michael Pittman, who first played for the Steelers in 2026.

Show all 25 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the Colts and the Steelers (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
PlayerColtsSteelersFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
Michael Pittman95252020–2025302026Colts
Darrius Heyward-Bey17120137962014–2018Colts
Mike Mitchell8020186802014–2017Steelers
Sean Davis1020216902016–2020Steelers
Joe Haeg5602016–20191302021Colts
Mike Hilton2020256102017–2020Steelers
Donte Moncrief56192014–2017502019Colts
Eric Ebron28182018–20192482020–2021Colts
Chris Wormley5020254302020–2022Steelers
Al Woods2902017–20181602013Steelers
Sean Spence3020173902014–2017Steelers
Arthur Maulet5020183402021–2022Colts
Trey Sermon3122023–2024402025Colts
Ricardo Mathews18020131702016Colts
Quincy Wilson3002017–2019102022Colts
Jon Bostic14020171602018Colts
Jordan Todman16120161302015Steelers
Chris Carter1002014–20161302013Steelers
Chaz Green1602020202021Colts
Buddy Johnson1202025402021Steelers
Deon Cain702019802019–2020Colts
J.J. Wilcox3020181202017Steelers
John Simon912017102021Colts
Cassius Marsh302020202020Colts
Tre Flowers102024102025Colts

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the Colts and the Steelers have met 11 times: the Colts won 2, the Steelers 9.

  • Colts' biggest win: Colts 30-13 Steelers (2023)
  • Steelers' biggest win: Steelers 45-10 Colts (2015)

More pairs

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

Steelers also shares players with

Every Steelers pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the Colts and the Steelers?
25 in the NFL since 2013: Michael Pittman, Darrius Heyward-Bey, Mike Mitchell, Sean Davis, Joe Haeg, Mike Hilton and 19 more.
Has anyone scored for both the Colts and the Steelers?
Yes, 2: Eric Ebron (18 and 8) and Darrius Heyward-Bey (1 and 6).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the Colts and the Steelers?
Michael Pittman. He played for the Colts (2020–2025), then the Steelers from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.