Players who played for the Bills and the Colts

19 players · NFL since 2013

19 players have played for both the Bills and the Colts in the NFL since 2013. 10 played for the Bills first and 9 for the Colts first. The longest-serving played 87 games across both; the top scorer got 22 touchdowns; 4 scored for both; the first move came in 2013, the most recent in 2026.

Can you name all 19?

0/190:00

  1.  Bills 74 · Colts 13
  2.  Bills 11 · Colts 73
  3.  Bills 1 · Colts 71
  4.  Bills 52 · Colts 15
  5.  Bills 17 · Colts 48
  6.  Bills 57 · Colts 1
  7.  Bills 32 · Colts 22
  8.  Bills 34 · Colts 8
  9.  Bills 8 · Colts 34
  10.  Bills 7 · Colts 32
  11.  Bills 36 · Colts 2
  12.  Bills 4 · Colts 31
  13.  Bills 18 · Colts 16
  14.  Bills 2 · Colts 30
  15.  Bills 2 · Colts 19
  16.  Bills 11 · Colts 9
  17.  Bills 12 · Colts 5
  18.  Bills 7 · Colts 3
  19.  Bills 1 · Colts 5

Who stands out

Spoilers

Isaiah McKenzie has the most games for the two combined: 74 for the Bills and 13 for the Colts. Nyheim Hines scored the most touchdowns across both (3 for the Bills, 19 for the Colts), and 4 players scored for both.

In our data, Tashard Choice was the first to have played for both (his first game for the Colts came in 2013). The most recent player to play for both is Sedrick Van Pran-Granger, who first played for the Colts in 2026.

Show all 19 players

Spoilers
Every player who played for the Bills and the Colts (NFL since 2013): games and touchdowns at each, seasons, and which team came first.
PlayerBillsColtsFirst
GTDsSeasonsGTDsSeasons
Isaiah McKenzie74172018–20221302023Bills
Nyheim Hines113202273192018–2022Colts
Vontae Davis1020187102013–2017Colts
Stephon Gilmore5202013–20161502022Bills
Frank Gore172201948192015–2017Colts
Duke Williams5712013–2016102016Bills
Zack Moss32102020–20222282022–2023Bills
Sedrick Van Pran-Granger3402024–2025802026Bills
Sergio Brown8020163402013–2014Colts
Colt Anderson702016–20173202014–2015Colts
Ike Boettger3602018–2022202023Bills
Dan Herron4020153132013–2015Colts
Matt Haack18020211602022Bills
Xavier Rhodes2020223012020–2021Colts
Mike Badgley2020251902021–2025Colts
Jonathan Williams1112016912019Bills
Tashard Choice1202013502013Bills
Ryan Lewis702018302019Bills
Kameron Cline102024502020–2022Colts

Head to head

In the NFL since 2013, the Bills and the Colts have met 6 times: the Bills won 4, the Colts 2.

  • Bills' biggest win: Bills 27-14 Colts (2015)
  • Colts' biggest win: Colts 37-5 Bills (2018)

More pairs

Bills also shares players with

Every Bills pair

Colts also shares players with

Every Colts pair

Play

FAQ

Spoilers
How many players have played for both the Bills and the Colts?
19 in the NFL since 2013: Isaiah McKenzie, Nyheim Hines, Vontae Davis, Stephon Gilmore, Frank Gore, Duke Williams and 13 more.
Has anyone scored for both the Bills and the Colts?
Yes, 4: Nyheim Hines (3 and 19), Frank Gore (2 and 19), Zack Moss (10 and 8) and Jonathan Williams (1 and 1).
Who is the most recent player to play for both the Bills and the Colts?
Sedrick Van Pran-Granger. He played for the Bills (2024–2025), then the Colts from 2026.
What period does this list cover?
NFL games from 2013 to the present, updated as new games are played. Earlier games aren't in our data, so all-time lists can be longer.

Data: NFL since 2013; touchdowns are ones scored, not thrown. Earlier games aren't included, so all-time lists can be longer.